home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=93TT2184>
- <title>
- Sep. 06, 1993: How Low Can They Go?
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1993
- Sep. 06, 1993 Boom Time In The Rockies
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- THE ECONOMY, Page 46
- How Low Can They Go?
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p>Falling interest rates have become the most powerful force in
- a balky economy
- </p>
- <p>By JOHN GREENWALD--With reporting by Dan Goodgame/Washington, Adrian J.W. Maher/Los
- Angeles, William McWhirter/Detroit and Frederick Ungeheuer/New
- York
- </p>
- <p> Marc Cohen, a homeowner in Woodland Hills, California, has
- a new annual chore. For the past three years in a row, he has
- re financed his family's five-bedroom house. "My wife says,
- `You must be kidding--you're doing it again?'" says Cohen,
- a Merrill Lynch vice president. "It's a pain to do it, but for
- three weeks of aggravation, you get years of savings on the
- interest." For his trouble, Cohen now enjoys a 15-year mortgage
- fixed at 6 3/4%, down from the 11 1/2% adjustable-rate loan
- he originally took out in 1989. His total monthly savings on
- the payments: $2,000.
- </p>
- <p> Such bargains reflect the financial environment of the 1990s,
- a period in which interest rates are the lowest in decades and
- the stock market is setting record highs. With inflation and
- economic growth both down to a crawl, the low cost of borrowing
- has become the prime mover of the tepid U.S. economic recovery
- and the key to how Americans save and invest.
- </p>
- <p> The most dramatic effect is on Wall Street, where the Dow Jones
- industrial average hit new highs in back-to-back sessions last
- week as consumers, with increasing boldness, shifted their cash
- from low-yielding bank deposits into stocks and bonds. The Dow
- closed at 3640.63, up 25.15 points for the week. At the same
- time, buyers stampeded to buy long-term bonds in order to lock
- in rates before they fall any further. Nor were U.S. investors
- on a solitary binge: hopes for a fall in European loan rates
- pushed stock exchanges in London and Paris to new highs last
- week.
- </p>
- <p> In many ways, the new era is a mirror image of the buoyant 1980s,
- when inflation and economic growth were higher and debt was
- desirable. Consumers, businesses and the U.S. government borrowed
- like mad because they figured the economic boom would keep income
- and salaries growing faster than the debt. Now that growth has
- slowed, the mentality has changed completely. The Clinton Administration
- is increasing taxes to fight the deficit, and consumers and
- corporations are frantically digging out of debt. "I encourage
- people to wipe the 1980s from their minds from the point of
- view of investment strategy, because the hyper inflation and
- high interest rates are gone," says Allen Sinai, chief economist
- for Economic Advisors, a consulting firm. Today's investment
- climate looks more like the 1950s and '60s, Sinai says, when
- inflation and interest rates were reliably low year after year.
- </p>
- <p> While a more robust recovery would put people back to work faster,
- the slow but steady tempo has a positive side of its own. Among
- other things, it gives investors the confidence to put their
- money in longer-term investments. On Wall Street outspoken bulls
- insist that the stock market still has plenty of room to grow.
- Elaine Garzarelli, an investment strategist for Lehman Bros.,
- looks for the Dow to hit 4000 by the end of the year and climb
- to 4600 in 1994. "My feeling is that any correction would be
- minor," Garzarelli says. "Interest rates would have to go up
- to offer an alternative to money going into stocks."
- </p>
- <p> Stock mutual funds, which are growing at a record pace of $10
- billion a month, have been the big beneficiaries of the Wall
- Street stampede. At Fidelity Investments, the largest U.S. manager
- of mutual funds, executive vice president Neal Litvak said August
- was producing the heaviest volume of new business all year.
- The fresh money has been propping up stock prices as fund managers
- scramble to locate attractive issues to add to their portfolios.
- </p>
- <p> Investors who pull their savings out of banks generally head
- straight for conservative funds. Among the most popular are
- balanced funds, which combine blue-chip stocks with high-quality
- bonds. Asset-managing funds, which diversify their investments
- among stocks, bonds and money-market instruments, are also
- on a roll. Hottest of all are tax-free bond funds, which customers
- have been snapping up in response to the Administration's tax
- hikes.
- </p>
- <p> While declining interest rates have been a boon to the stock
- market, they have left some cautious investors--particularly
- elderly people who rely on the interest from their savings--lagging behind. "Obviously, savers are penalized," says Donald
- Clark, chairman of Household International, a major consumer-finance
- firm. "If you have all your money in CDs, you're really hurting."
- In 1990, when rates on savings accounts averaged 7.9%, people
- who held one-year bank deposits earned $16 billion in interest
- payments. Today, with rates at less than half that level, those
- same little-guy savers are earning just $4.9 billion on their
- money.
- </p>
- <p> Even so, Wall Street is genuinely divided on the subject; some
- gurus caution investors to stick with their modest interest
- income rather than shift their savings to riskier securities.
- Reason: a sudden spurt in interest rates could drive stock and
- bond prices down. "A lot of investors who are selling their
- CDs at 3%, and who keep buying bonds with yields above 6%, are
- not aware that they are risking capital," says Peter Canelo,
- chief market strategist for NatWest Securities. "People should
- not be investing in stocks or bonds," he warns. "They should
- stay in 6- to 30-month CDs."
- </p>
- <p> In fact, the fate of stock and bond portfolios now depends to
- an extraordinary degree on the prospects for interest rates.
- While predicting what rates may do is always an iffy proposition,
- economists generally expect them to remain low for the next
- 18 months and perhaps even fall a bit more. That's because the
- slo-mo recovery shows no real signs of pushing up inflation,
- and interest rates reflect the level of inflation more than
- anything else.
- </p>
- <p> For all their power over the markets, however, low rates have
- added little real zest to the American economy, which has been
- growing less than 2% a year. The effect of the Clinton Administration's
- tax increases and deficit reduction will probably be a wash.
- Presidential advisers credit the deficit-cutting plan with fostering
- a decline of 1 1/2 percentage points in long-term interest rates
- since November, which they say will provide the equivalent of
- at least $50 billion a year in fiscal stimulation. While many
- private analysts dispute the Administration's calculations,
- Laura Tyson, Clinton's top economist, retorts, "If we had done
- nothing, we probably would have seen a rise in interest rates
- that would have choked off the recovery."
- </p>
- <p> Still, consumersoworry about the prospect of additional taxes
- to pay for health-care reform. And they remain too nervous about
- their jobs to increase their spending much. Gauges of consumer
- confidence have fallen steadily since April. "In some sense,
- I've got a greater feeling of security today," says Michael
- Segal, a Los Angeles real estate investor. "I've refinanced
- my home three times, and I feel more at ease with the purchases
- I make. However, there is an unanticipated something out there,
- a fear of the unknown. There should be even more security than
- there is, but it just isn't there."
- </p>
- <p> If the economy stays in low gear and inflation remains dormant,
- further rate drops could keep the bulls running on Wall Street
- and create another frenzied wave of mortgage refinancing. Before
- interest rates plunged in recent years, homeowners clung to
- a rule of thumb that said people should refinance only when
- rates fell at least two percentage points below the interest
- on their existing loans. Under that formula, the gains from
- lower mortgage rates would exceed the closing costs on the refinancing.
- But today banks and mortgage brokers offer so many refinancing
- options that canny rate surfers can replace their mortgages
- at little cost. Since 1991, consumers have refinanced $1 trillion
- worth of mortgages, or fully one-third of all U.S. home loans.
- </p>
- <p> For the economy as a whole, the chief benefit from low rates
- has been the chance for consumers and companies to ease the
- debt burden that the '80s left behind. Economists say that should
- pave the way for stronger growth by 1995. Weary Americans might
- be forgiven, however, for thinking the promised land is still
- a long way off. "Lower interest rates won't do it alone for
- us or for our dealers," says Allan Gilmour, vice chairman of
- Ford Motor Co. "Their steam has just about run out. The economy's
- biggest problem is that it needs an igniter to get the whole
- thing going." President Clinton tried that with his deficit-spending
- proposal to boost the economy earlier this year, but his attempt
- stirred little public enthusiasm and was defeated by Congress.
- Without any such stimulus, low interest rates are likely to
- remain the only road to restoring the confidence of consumers
- and encouraging companies to start hiring again.
- </p>
-
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-